The Jacobite Rising of 1745 and Battle of Culloden

The rising of 1745 — 'The Forty-Five' — was the last and most dramatic attempt to restore the House of Stuart to the British throne, and it came closer to success than its ultimate fate might suggest. Charles Edward Stuart, the 'Young Pretender' and grandson of James II, landed on the Hebridean island of Eriskay in July 1745 with just seven companions and a consuming certainty that the Highland clans would rise for him. They did. Within weeks he had assembled an army and captured Edinburgh virtually without resistance, defeating a government force at the Battle of Prestonpans in a battle that lasted barely ten minutes. The march south into England in November 1745 reached as far as Derby — closer to London than any foreign invader had penetrated in centuries. The Hanoverian court briefly panicked; King George II reportedly packed his bags. But English Jacobite support never materialised in the numbers Charles had promised his reluctant Highland commanders, and at a council of war at Derby on December 5 the Jacobite chiefs voted, over Charles's furious objections, to retreat back to Scotland. That decision at Derby — 'Black Friday' as Charles called it — effectively ended any realistic prospect of a Stuart restoration, though the campaign continued for months. The retreat northward was harried by government forces, and the Jacobite army suffered its cohesion and morale deteriorating through the Scottish winter. The final confrontation came on Culloden Moor near Inverness on April 16, 1746, chosen by Charles over the objections of his experienced Irish lieutenant Lord George Murray as a flat, open field entirely unsuitable for the Highland charge that was the Jacobite army's principal tactic. The government army under William Augustus, Duke of Cumberland — younger son of George II — numbered around nine thousand disciplined regular troops equipped with artillery. Against them Charles deployed between five and six thousand men, many exhausted after a failed night march and half-starved from supply failures. The battle lasted less than an hour. Government artillery tore apart the Jacobite lines as they waited for the order to charge; when the charge finally came it was unsupported, piecemeal, and met by disciplined musket fire and a new bayonet drill designed to neutralise the Highland broadsword. The Jacobite army was shattered. Cumberland's pursuit of the fleeing Highlanders was merciless — wounded men were killed on the field, prisoners executed, and a systematic campaign of terror conducted through the Highlands in the weeks following, earning Cumberland the enduring nickname 'Butcher' among Scots. The political consequences of Culloden extended far beyond the battlefield. Westminster used the rising as justification for a comprehensive assault on Highland society: the Heritable Jurisdictions Act abolished the private courts that Highland chiefs had used to enforce their authority, the Dress Act banned Highland dress including the tartan plaid, Gaelic was suppressed in schools, and the bearing of arms was forbidden. These measures accelerated processes of agricultural change and landlord commercialisation that would later be called the Highland Clearances, depopulating vast areas of the Highlands over the following century as sheep replaced people on profitable commercial estates. Bonnie Prince Charlie spent the rest of his life in European exile, dying in Rome in 1788 — a bloated, embittered alcoholic whose romantic legend grew precisely in inverse proportion to his personal decline.

Related

MyHistorian
A causal knowledge graph of history